
Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel
Best for families, pets and guests who want direct South Beach access with a lively pool and public beach club.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel is a 4.5-star, Art Deco oceanfront hotel on South Beach that suits families, pet owners and travelers who want a lively beach-and-pool scene. The St. Regis Bal Harbour Resort is a prestige five-star beachfront resort in Bal Harbour aimed at travelers seeking larger-scale luxury, a full-service spa and curated conference/event facilities.
Updated · about 13 km (≈8 miles) apart

Best for families, pets and guests who want direct South Beach access with a lively pool and public beach club.

Best for travelers who want formal five-star service, larger meeting/event space and multiple on-site restaurants and pools.
When Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel wins: choose the Surfcomber if you want a compact, social South Beach stay — direct beach access, a single heated pool with weekend DJs, a family-friendly program (DAYLIFE) and a pet-friendly policy with no pet fees.
When The St. Regis Bal Harbour Resort wins: choose the St. Regis for a more formal, full-service luxury experience — more rooms, two outdoor pools, a large full-service spa, multiple restaurants and extensive meeting/conference space.
Bottom line: pick the Surfcomber for an energetic South Beach vibe, easier walking access to Lincoln Road and Ocean Drive, and family/pet-friendly amenities. Pick the St. Regis for a classic five-star resort stay in quieter Bal Harbour with more on-site facilities and meeting capacity.
| Category | Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel | The St. Regis Bal Harbour Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique Art Deco, social pool scene, lively South Beach location | Prestige five-star resort, formal luxury on a quieter Bal Harbour beachfront |
| Location | 1717 Collins Avenue — directly on South Beach, walking distance to Lincoln Road and Ocean Drive | 9703 Collins Avenue — beachfront in Bal Harbour, near Bal Harbour Shops |
| Size / rooms | About 186 rooms (oceanfront boutique scale) | 213 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages; family-friendly with kids' activities and kids stay free with existing bedding | All ages; not adults-only |
| Pools | One outdoor heated pool with cabanas, weekend DJs and poolside service | Two outdoor pools, pool sun loungers and poolside bars |
| Beach access & amenities | Direct South Beach access via gated paths; beach chairs provided (resort fee) and rentable umbrellas/daybeds | Beaches in front of the property; beach cabanas and beach sun loungers (surcharge) |
| Restaurants & bars | The Social Club (signature) and Solei Beach Club (poolside Mediterranean) | Four restaurants including Atlantikós (Greek) and multiple bars/lounges |
| Spa & wellness | K'Alma Spa with coffee-infused signature treatments plus 24-hour fitness and beach yoga | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments and facials; 24-hour fitness center |
| Events & meeting space | Multiple small indoor/outdoor venues; about 3,120 sq ft indoor plus large outdoor event space (weddings up to ~600) | Extensive conference space (17,651 ft²) and 9 meeting rooms |
| Pets | Pet-friendly with no pet fee and no weight limits | Pets allowed by arrangement (supplier listing notes pet policies and fees) |
Kimpton Surfcomber sits at 1717 Collins Avenue in Miami Beach's Art Deco district with immediate access to the boardwalk and South Beach.
Pick Surfcomber for walking distance to South Beach nightlife, restaurants and cultural sites.
The St. Regis Bal Harbour Resort occupies beachfront property on Collins Avenue in Bal Harbour, a quieter neighborhood north of Miami Beach.
Pick the St. Regis if you prefer a more tranquil, upscale neighborhood with luxury shopping nearby.
Surfcomber offers roughly 186 rooms and suites, including multiple oceanfront room and suite types.
Surfcomber suits families and travelers who want compact, practical oceanfront rooms with direct beach access.
The St. Regis lists 213 individually decorated guestrooms and a wide range of suites from Grand Luxe rooms to multi-bedroom Royal and Presidential suites.
St. Regis is a better fit if you want a wide choice of large suites and traditionally luxurious room amenities.
Kimpton Surfcomber centers dining around The Social Club and the poolside Solei Beach Club.
Choose Surfcomber if you prefer a compact, walkable dining program tied to the pool and Collins Avenue.
St. Regis Bal Harbour lists four on-site restaurants, including Atlantikós (Greek) and room service during limited hours.
St. Regis works well for guests who want several on-site restaurant choices without leaving the property.
Surfcomber features one outdoor heated pool, poolside cabanas and direct access to South Beach.
Surfcomber is ideal if you want quick pool-to-beach flow and a social pool atmosphere.
St. Regis provides two outdoor pools, pool sun loungers and beach cabanas (surcharges may apply).
St. Regis is better if you want more pool variety and formal cabana/poolside services.
Kimpton Surfcomber offers the K'Alma Spa, regular fitness classes and an active South Beach nightlife nearby.
Surfcomber fits travelers who want a mix of spa treatments and immediate access to South Beach nightlife.
The St. Regis offers a full-service spa with a broad menu of massages, body treatments and facials alongside 24-hour fitness.
St. Regis is the pick when on-site spa services and curated resort programming matter more than neighborhood nightlife.

Kimpton Surfcomber — kids' DAYLIFE activities, kids stay free policies and easy beach access.

The St. Regis Bal Harbour Resort — larger suite roster, individually decorated rooms and classic five-star service.

Kimpton Surfcomber — no pet fee, no weight restrictions and pet amenities on arrival.

The St. Regis Bal Harbour Resort — about 17,651 ft² of conference space and nine meeting rooms.
Kimpton Surfcomber — it explicitly markets family-friendly programming, kids stay free in existing bedding and offers DAYLIFE activities and beach access suitable for children.
The St. Regis lists four restaurants and multiple bars; Surfcomber has two primary venues (The Social Club and Solei Beach Club).
Yes — both properties offer direct beach access, though they sit in different neighborhoods (South Beach vs Bal Harbour).
Kimpton Surfcomber is in the heart of South Beach within walking distance of Lincoln Road, Ocean Drive and the Miami Beach Boardwalk; St. Regis is in quieter Bal Harbour, where most dining and shopping is concentrated around Bal Harbour Shops.
Explore how Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·