
Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel
Best for beach-and-scene stays in South Beach, walking to Lincoln Road and Ocean Drive.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel is a 4.5-star, family-friendly Art Deco beachfront hotel on South Beach for travelers who want beach access plus nightlife and walking access to Lincoln Road. The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne, Miami is a secluded five-star island beach resort on Key Biscayne for travelers who prefer a quieter, resort-style stay with extensive on-site facilities.
Updated · about 16 km apart

Best for beach-and-scene stays in South Beach, walking to Lincoln Road and Ocean Drive.

Best for a quieter, full-service resort experience with multiple restaurants, courts and spa on Key Biscayne.
When Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel wins: choose the Surfcomber if you want immediate South Beach access, an active pool vibe (weekend DJs), short walks to Lincoln Road and Ocean Drive, and a smaller boutique feel close to Miami Beach nightlife.
When The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne, Miami wins: pick the Ritz-Carlton for a larger five-star resort with wide on-site facilities (multiple restaurants and bars, full-service spa, tennis complex, marina/boating access) and a quieter island setting away from South Beach crowds.
Bottom line: Surfcomber is the better pick for a compact South Beach experience with walkable attractions and a lively pool scene; The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne is the choice for travelers after a more self-contained, luxury resort stay on an island setting.
| Category | Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel | The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne, Miami |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique Art Deco beach hotel with an energetic South Beach scene | Secluded five-star island resort with resort-scale facilities |
| Location | 1717 Collins Avenue — on South Beach, steps from the boardwalk, Lincoln Road and Ocean Drive | 455 Grand Bay Dr, Key Biscayne — island beachfront, quieter and farther from downtown Miami |
| Size (rooms) | 186 rooms | 421 rooms |
| Who it's for | All ages — families, pet owners, beachgoers who want nightlife nearby | All ages — guests who want a quieter five-star resort stay with resort amenities |
| Pools & beach access | 1 outdoor heated pool, direct South Beach access through gates, poolside DJs on weekends | 2 outdoor pools and direct walk-to-beach access on Key Biscayne |
| Restaurants & bars | The Social Club (signature) + Solei Beach Club (poolside); in-room dining available | Five restaurants, 3 bars/lounges and 2 poolside bars; 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | K'Alma Spa with coffee-infused signature treatments, 24-hour fitness center, beach yoga | Full-service spa offering massages, body treatments and facials; fitness classes on site |
| Meetings & events | Multiple indoor/outdoor venues, ~3,120 sq ft indoor + large outdoor event space for weddings/corporate | Large conference capacity — 30,000 sq ft of conference and meeting space |
| Family & pets | Family-friendly with kids' programs and pet-friendly (no pet fee) | Family-friendly (up to 2 children 18 and younger stay free); pet policy: Not published |
| Typical check-in/check-out | Check-in from 4:00 PM; check-out 11:00 AM | |
Kimpton Surfcomber sits directly on South Beach in Miami Beach's Art Deco district — an easy walk to Lincoln Road, Ocean Drive and the Miami Beach Convention Center.
Pick Surfcomber if you want to be in the middle of South Beach attractions and nightlife.
The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne is located on Key Biscayne, offering a quieter island beachfront location away from downtown Miami.
Choose the Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne for a calmer beachfront setting removed from South Beach activity.
Kimpton Surfcomber offers a smaller set of Art Deco–influenced rooms and suites, several oceanfront options and pet-friendly policies.
If you prefer a boutique, design-forward room on South Beach with pet-friendly policies, Surfcomber fits.
The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne has a large inventory of rooms and suites with many room-view options (resort, bay and ocean views).
Ritz-Carlton offers a wide selection of room types and views for longer resort stays or groups.
Surfcomber centers dining around The Social Club and Solei Beach Club for poolside and Collins Avenue dining.
Surfcomber is good for focused, popular on-site dining with easy walkable options nearby.
The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne lists five restaurants, three bars and two poolside bars offering a wider range of on-site dining and beverage outlets.
Ritz-Carlton has more on-site dining and bar choices, useful if you plan to spend most of your time at the resort.
Surfcomber has a single heated outdoor pool with cabanas and a lively weekend DJ scene plus direct access to South Beach.
Surfcomber's pool is social and convenient for South Beach activity and people-watching.
The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne lists two outdoor pools, beach cabanas (surcharge) and extensive beach facilities.
Ritz-Carlton provides more pool space and a broader set of on-water activities for resort-style downtime.
Kimpton Surfcomber focuses on a boutique spa (K'Alma Spa), regular wellness classes and a nightlife-adjacent location.
Surfcomber mixes beach-based wellness with immediate access to Miami Beach nightlife.
The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne includes a full-service spa and a broader fitness and sports program on site.
Ritz-Carlton is likely the better fit for guests who want full spa and sports programming within the resort footprint.

Kimpton Surfcomber — steps from Lincoln Road, Ocean Drive and the Miami Beach Boardwalk.

The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne — more restaurants, bars, pools and large meeting/conference space.

Kimpton Surfcomber — kids' programs, free kid stays and pet-friendly policies with no fee.

The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne — island location and resort setup suited to longer relaxation-focused stays.
Kimpton Surfcomber on South Beach is generally closer to downtown attractions and quicker to reach from MIA; Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne requires a drive across the Rickenbacker Causeway and is quieter but farther from downtown.
Yes. Both hotels welcome families. Kimpton Surfcomber highlights kids' activities and a family-friendly pool; the Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne allows up to 2 children 18 and under to stay free with a registered adult.
The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne has more on-site restaurants, bars, pools, tennis courts and meeting space, making it better suited to guests who plan to stay on-property most of the time.
Kimpton Surfcomber is explicitly pet-friendly with no pet fee and pet amenities. The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne's supplier listing notes a pet fee in its optional fees section (pets allowed with fees), and service animals are exempt.
Explore how Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·