
Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel
Best for families and active beach stays — direct South Beach access, kids' programming, free bikes and a heated pool with weekend DJs.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel is a 4.5-star oceanfront Art Deco resort on South Beach with family-friendly programming, a heated pool, and on-site spa—good for beach-focused families and groups who want direct beach access. The Shelborne By Proper is an upscale, restored Collins Avenue beachfront hotel with Design Hotel styling—good for travelers who want a stylish, larger-property feel a short walk from Lincoln Road and South Beach nightlife.
Updated · about 0.2 km apart (roughly two blocks)

Best for families and active beach stays — direct South Beach access, kids' programming, free bikes and a heated pool with weekend DJs.

Best for travelers who want a larger, design-driven beachfront hotel with more meeting and banquet space close to Lincoln Road.
When Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel wins: choose Surfcomber if you want a family-friendly, boutique Art Deco beach resort with direct beach access, a recognized on-site spa (K'Alma Spa), poolside programming and well-known restaurant venues (The Social Club and Solei Beach Club).
When The Shelborne By Proper wins: pick The Shelborne if you prefer an upscale restored Collins Avenue beachfront hotel with larger conference and event space, multiple bars/lounges and easy access to Lincoln Road and the Miami Beach Boardwalk in a Design Hotels property.
Bottom line: both sit on Collins Avenue within a short walk of the same South Beach attractions; Surfcomber leans toward active families and spa/pool-driven stays, while The Shelborne skews toward travelers who want an upscale, conference-ready beachfront option close to Lincoln Road.
| Category | Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel | The Shelborne By Proper |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Oceanfront Art Deco boutique resort with a lively pool scene and family programming | Upscale, restored Design Hotel on Collins with a resort-style feel and multiple bars/lounges |
| Location | 1717 Collins Avenue — directly on South Beach; short walk to Lincoln Road, Ocean Drive and the boardwalk | 1801 Collins Avenue — beachfront on Collins Avenue, steps from Collins Avenue Shopping Area and the boardwalk |
| Size (rooms) | 186 rooms (oceanfront property, boutique scale) | 251 rooms (larger property) |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; family-friendly with kids' activities | All ages welcome; not adults-only |
| Pools & beach | One outdoor heated pool, poolside cabanas, direct gated access to the beach | One outdoor pool and private beach access with free beach cabanas and beach loungers |
| Restaurants & bars | The Social Club (signature restaurant) + Solei Beach Club poolside venue; in-room dining available | One on-site restaurant (Pauline) plus 3 bars/lounges, a beach bar and a coffee shop/cafe |
| Spa & wellness | On-site K'Alma Spa with coffee-infused signature treatments and 24-hour fitness center | On-site fitness facilities and spa access listed as available (detailed spa name/services not published in the supplier listing) |
| Meetings & events | Smaller indoor meeting footprint (3,120 sq ft) plus large outdoor event space; multiple private venues for weddings and meetings | Large conference footprint (30000 sq ft) with 6 meeting rooms and significant indoor event space |
| Accessibility & family policy | Family-friendly; pets allowed; wheelchair-accessible path of travel and accessible rooms | All ages welcome; multiple accessible features listed (visual alarms, wheelchair-accessible registration desk and spa with limitations) |
| Free WiFi | Yes — complimentary throughout the property | |
Kimpton Surfcomber sits at 1717 Collins Avenue with direct gated access to South Beach and quick walks to Lincoln Road and Ocean Drive.
Choose Surfcomber if you want to step from the pool onto the sand and be minutes from South Beach sights.
The Shelborne sits at 1801 Collins Avenue, beachfront and close to Collins Avenue shopping and the Miami Beach Boardwalk.
Choose The Shelborne if you want an upscale Collins Avenue beach stay within easy walking distance of Lincoln Road.
Surfcomber offers a mix of room types including oceanfront suites and premium oceanfront rooms in a 186-room Art Deco setting.
Surfcomber is focused on beach-view rooms and family-ready suites in a boutique footprint.
The Shelborne has 251 air-conditioned rooms in a restored design-hotel package with a wide range of city- and ocean-view options.
The Shelborne is a larger property with more room varieties and several oceanfront and balcony options.
Surfcomber’s dining centers on The Social Club and the poolside Solei Beach Club, both open to locals and guests.
Surfcomber is a recognized dining destination on Collins with two signature venues for different moods.
The Shelborne lists Pauline as its on-site restaurant, plus a beach bar, poolside bar and three lounges for drinks and light bites.
The Shelborne offers multiple on-site bars and a full restaurant, making it convenient for dining without leaving the property.
Surfcomber provides one heated outdoor pool, poolside cabanas, weekend DJs and direct sand access via gates.
Surfcomber focuses on an active pool scene that flows directly to the beach.
The Shelborne has an outdoor pool and a private beach offering complimentary beach cabanas and loungers.
The Shelborne offers both a pool and more formal private beach amenities useful for guests who want beach service included.
Surfcomber provides a full-service spa (K'Alma Spa), 24-hour fitness center and scheduled wellness classes like beach yoga and Splash Cycle.
Surfcomber is a strong choice if spa treatments and on-site fitness classes matter to you.
The Shelborne lists fitness classes on site and accessible wellness features; nightlife and bars are steps away on Collins and Lincoln Road.
The Shelborne suits travelers who want on-site bars plus quick access to South Beach nightlife and nearby evening options.

Kimpton Surfcomber — kids' DAYLIFE activities, family-friendly rooms and direct beach access make it an easier pick for families.

The Shelborne — larger conference footprint (30000 sq ft) and six meeting rooms suit bigger meetings and banquets.

Kimpton Surfcomber — K'Alma Spa, scheduled fitness classes and beach yoga are prominent on property.

The Shelborne — 251 rooms and multiple bars/lounges make it a better fit if you want a larger, resort-style beachfront property.
Kimpton Surfcomber — it is explicitly family-friendly with kids' activities, family room options and direct gated beach access.
Yes. Both properties are beachfront on Collins Avenue with pool access and beach amenities; The Shelborne lists a private beach with free cabanas.
The Shelborne — supplier data lists about 30000 sq ft of conference space and six meeting rooms, compared with Surfcomber’s smaller indoor meeting footprint and larger outdoor event space.
No — both properties offer breakfast for an additional fee; room rates do not include breakfast by default.
Explore how Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·