
Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel
Best for families and guests who want a classic South Beach Art Deco stay with one main heated pool, direct boardwalk access and a lively poolside vibe.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel is a 4.5-star, family-friendly Art Deco oceanfront hotel on South Beach that suits travelers who want direct beach access, active programming, and a social pool scene. 1 Hotel South Beach is a 5-star luxury oceanfront eco-chic resort on Collins Avenue for travelers who want larger-scale luxury, multiple pools and restaurants, and a pronounced wellness/spa focus.
Updated · about 1.0 km apart

Best for families and guests who want a classic South Beach Art Deco stay with one main heated pool, direct boardwalk access and a lively poolside vibe.

Best for travelers seeking a larger luxury resort experience with more pools, more dining options, and a bigger on-site spa and meeting footprint.
When Kimpton Surfcomber wins: choose Surfcomber if you want a smaller, Art Deco beachfront hotel with family programming, an active single pool with weekend DJs, easy access to Lincoln Road and the boardwalk, and on-site dining geared to a beach crowd.
When 1 Hotel South Beach wins: choose 1 Hotel for a full luxury resort experience — multiple outdoor pools, a larger spa and wellness program, more restaurants and bars, and extensive meeting and event space.
Bottom line: both are oceanfront on Collins Avenue and put you on South Beach, but Surfcomber is the boutique, family-friendly Art Deco choice with a single social pool and direct boardwalk access; 1 Hotel South Beach is the larger, luxury eco-focused resort with more pools, dining venues, and event facilities.
| Category | Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel | 1 Hotel South Beach |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Art Deco boutique, lively pool & beach programming | Luxury oceanfront resort, eco-driven design and larger-scale amenities |
| Location (Collins Ave) | 1717 Collins Avenue — direct beach access, steps to boardwalk and Lincoln Road | |
| Size / rooms | 186 rooms (oceanfront boutique scale) | 426 guestrooms (larger resort footprint) |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; family-friendly with kids' programming | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools | One outdoor heated pool with cabanas, weekend DJs and poolside service | Three outdoor pools plus multiple pool bars and cabanas |
| Restaurants & bars | The Social Club (signature restaurant) and Solei Beach Club (poolside) | Three restaurants, six bars/lounges, 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | K'Alma Spa with coffee-infused signature treatments and fitness classes (24-hour fitness center) | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments, facials and extensive fitness offerings |
| Event & meeting space | Multiple indoor/outdoor venues; about 3,120 sq ft indoor + 50,000 sq ft outdoor (event capacity up to ~600) | Large conference center with ~25,005 sq ft (2323 m²) of event space |
| Childcare & family | Children's activities (DAYLIFE), cribs and family menus; kids stay free with existing bedding | Babysitting/childcare available (surcharge); playground and children's pool listed |
| Sustainability / signature features | Historic Art Deco property renovated for modern beach stays | Positioned as an eco-chic luxury resort with electric car charging and eco-tours nearby |
Kimpton Surfcomber sits at 1717 Collins Avenue with direct access to the boardwalk and South Beach sand.
Choose Surfcomber for immediate boardwalk/beach access and close walking distance to South Beach attractions.
1 Hotel South Beach is an oceanfront property at 2341 Collins Avenue in central South Beach.
Choose 1 Hotel if you want a large beachfront resort footprint in central South Beach.
Surfcomber offers 13 room types, including oceanfront suites and premium oceanfront rooms.
Surfcomber’s rooms emphasize an Art Deco beachfront stay with several oceanfront options at boutique scale.
1 Hotel South Beach has a broad room mix across 426 guestrooms with many suite and balcony options.
1 Hotel is a better fit if you need a wider range of suite sizes and specialized oceanview or multi-bedroom configurations.
Surfcomber’s dining centers on The Social Club and Solei Beach Club, both focused on coastal/Mediterranean-influenced menus.
Surfcomber keeps dining focused and walkable with two main venues suited to beach crowds.
1 Hotel offers more on-site choices with three restaurants and six bars/lounges.
1 Hotel is better when you want variety and multiple on-site restaurant/bar environments.
Surfcomber has one outdoor heated pool with DJs on weekends and poolside cabanas.
Surfcomber focuses activity around one lively pool that connects directly to the beach.
1 Hotel South Beach lists three outdoor pools, plus pool bars and cabana services.
1 Hotel offers more pool variety and separate pool atmospheres if you prefer multiple pool choices.
Surfcomber emphasizes spa treatments, a 24-hour gym and scheduled wellness classes like beach yoga.
Surfcomber blends wellness services with active daytime pool energy and evening dining.
1 Hotel features a full-service spa, broad fitness options and a busy bar/restaurant nightlife program.
1 Hotel suits guests looking for a comprehensive spa and a larger evening dining/drink scene.

Kimpton Surfcomber — family programming, kids stay free policies and a single supervised pool area make it easy for families.

1 Hotel South Beach — three outdoor pools, more pool bars and larger resort services for varied pool experiences.

Kimpton Surfcomber — a renovated 1948 Art Deco property with a smaller, characterful footprint on Collins.

1 Hotel South Beach — an extensive conference center and dozens of meeting/banquet configurations for big events.
Kimpton Surfcomber is more family-focused with kids' activities (DAYLIFE), child amenities and policies that allow kids to stay free in existing bedding.
1 Hotel South Beach lists three outdoor pools, while Kimpton Surfcomber features one heated outdoor pool.
Yes. Both properties sit directly on Collins Avenue with direct access to the boardwalk and South Beach sand.
Neither property is adults-only; both welcome guests of all ages (1 Hotel South Beach is not adults-only).
Explore how Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·