
Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel
Best for families and guests who want direct South Beach access, a lively pool scene, and on-site activities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel is a 4.5-star, oceanfront Art Deco hotel on South Beach for travelers who want a family-friendly beachfront stay with poolside energy and daytime programming. Andaz Miami Beach Resort & Spa is a 5-star Mid-Beach resort geared toward travelers looking for an upscale beach-and-spa resort with larger facilities and a broader events program.
Updated · about 2.4 km apart

Best for families and guests who want direct South Beach access, a lively pool scene, and on-site activities.

Best for travelers who want a larger resort with multiple pools, a full-service spa, and more meeting/event rooms.
When Kimpton Surfcomber wins: Choose Surfcomber if you want a boutique Art Deco experience on South Beach, family-friendly programming (kids stay free, DAYLIFE activities), easy walkability to Lincoln Road and Ocean Drive, and a single heated pool with regular weekend DJ programming.
When Andaz wins: Choose Andaz Miami Beach Resort & Spa if you prefer a larger, 5-star resort footprint with two outdoor pools, an on-site full-service spa, more formal meeting and event space, and a broader set of resort amenities for groups and spa-focused stays.
Bottom line: Both are beachfront Miami Beach choices; pick Surfcomber for a more intimate, family-forward South Beach stay with a strong dining/pool vibe, and pick Andaz for a bigger, more traditional luxury resort and spa experience in Mid-Beach.
| Category | Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel | Andaz Miami Beach Resort & Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique Art Deco, active pool/beach programming | Upscale beachfront resort with resort-scale amenities |
| Location | South Beach (1717 Collins Avenue), walkable to Lincoln Road and Ocean Drive | Mid-Beach (4041 Collins Ave), beachfront near Miami Beach Boardwalk |
| Size (rooms) | 186 rooms | 287 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages; family-friendly (kids stay free, kids activities) | All ages; not adults-only |
| Pools | 1 outdoor heated pool with cabanas and weekend DJs | 2 outdoor pools (pool hours and rules published) |
| Restaurants & bars | The Social Club (signature) + Solei Beach Club (poolside), in-room dining | 2 restaurants, coffee shop/cafe, bar/lounge, beach bar, room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | K'Alma Spa with signature coffee-infused treatments; 24-hour fitness center and beach yoga | Full-service spa and fitness center; spa treatments and wellness offerings |
| Event & meeting space | Multiple indoor/outdoor venues; event capacity up to ~600; wedding beachfront options | 10 meeting rooms and a ballroom for events |
| Beach access | Direct South Beach access through gated paths; beach chairs included via resort fee | Beachfront with on-site beach club available (surcharge) |
| Pet policy | Pet-friendly with no pet fee and no weight limits | Pets accepted with surcharges (pet fee published) |
Kimpton Surfcomber sits on South Beach at 1717 Collins Avenue in the Art Deco district, within easy walking distance of Lincoln Road, Ocean Drive, and the Miami Beach Convention Center.
Surfcomber is better if you want immediate South Beach access and walkable nightlife and shopping.
Andaz Miami Beach Resort & Spa sits on Collins Avenue in Mid-Beach with beachfront access and proximity to the Miami Beach Boardwalk.
Andaz is a solid Mid-Beach option if you want a slightly quieter stretch of sand with easy boardwalk access.
Surfcomber offers a compact set of 13 room types, including oceanfront suites and premium oceanfront rooms.
Pick Surfcomber for classic Art Deco rooms with several oceanfront suite options in a smaller boutique inventory.
Andaz lists 287 guestrooms across a wide set of room and suite categories, including ocean-view and multi-bedroom terrace suites.
Andaz has a broader room mix and larger suite/terrace options for guests who want more room configurations.
Surfcomber centers food and drink around The Social Club and Solei Beach Club for poolside and Collins Avenue dining.
Surfcomber focuses on two signature venues that serve both guests and locals with a social, casual dining vibe.
Andaz offers multiple on-site dining venues including Mediterranean cuisine at Aguasal (José Andrés Group) and bar/lounge options.
Andaz provides more venue variety and a branded restaurant presence suitable for resort stays and groups.
Surfcomber has one heated outdoor pool with cabanas, umbrellas, and weekend DJs that feeds into the poolside dining scene.
Surfcomber is ideal for guests who want a single high-energy pool and immediate South Beach access.
Andaz lists two outdoor pools and a beach club on site (surcharges may apply) for a more traditional resort layout.
Andaz works better for guests who prefer multiple pool choices and a resort-club beach setup.
Surfcomber provides the K'Alma Spa, beach yoga, a 24-hour fitness center and scheduled wellness classes.
Surfcomber blends a small full-service spa with active fitness options and lively poolside entertainment.
Andaz features a full-service spa, fitness center and evening entertainment options across a larger property footprint.
Andaz is a good pick if you want a larger spa program and more evening venues within the resort.

Kimpton Surfcomber — kids stay free, DAYLIFE activities, and direct South Beach access make it family-friendly.

Andaz Miami Beach — larger spa and resort facilities with two pools and multiple wellness options.

Kimpton Surfcomber — single heated pool with cabanas and weekend DJs tied to poolside dining.

Andaz Miami Beach — a larger room count and 10 meeting rooms plus a ballroom suit conferences and events.
Kimpton Surfcomber — it's explicitly family-friendly with kids' activities, kids-eat-free info, and direct South Beach access.
Andaz Miami Beach — the supplier listing shows two outdoor pools and a broader set of resort-scale amenities.
Yes. Both properties sit on Collins Avenue with direct beach or boardwalk access; Surfcomber is on South Beach and Andaz in Mid-Beach.
No — neither property is adults-only; both welcome guests of all ages.
Explore how Kimpton Surfcomber Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·